分类帐BIP-44路径应包含四个元素还是五个元素?
-
-
您是否有机会获得Galleon示例的链接?快速的Google搜索没有发现任何问题.Do you have a link for the Galleon example by any chance? A quick Google search turned up nothing.
- 0
- 2019-01-29
- anonymous2
-
当我在MacOS上启动Galleon应用并连接到分类帐时,该应用本身会报告该路径.在https://aloha.pheme.app/@umurb/e25d7fbc-b40f-48d2-bdff-c4c2f0353818也有提及When I start up the Galleon app on MacOS and connect to ledger, the app itself reports that path. There is also some mention at https://aloha.pheme.app/@umurb/e25d7fbc-b40f-48d2-bdff-c4c2f0353818
- 0
- 2019-01-29
- Fred Yankowski
-
最终,这有点武断,但我认为尝试并尽可能遵循bip 44并使用5是有意义的.Ultimately it's a bit arbitrary, but I think it makes sense to try and follow bip 44 as much as possible and use 5.
- 0
- 2019-01-29
- Arthur B
-
1 个回答
- 投票数
-
- 2019-01-29
只要派生路径以44'/1729'开头,Ledger应用程序本身就支持2个组件至10个任意长度.这使Ledger支持这两种约定,并且这种支持将持续到不确定的将来.至于哪种约定更好,这是我作为Ledger开发人员所不能讨论的问题:-),但是并没有必要更改约定,任何好的工具都应允许您输入自定义路径.就个人而言,我使用tezos-client约定,因为我更喜欢命令行.
The Ledger app itself supports any length from 2 components up to 10, as long as the derivation path starts with 44'/1729'. This allows the Ledger to support either convention, and this support will continue into the indefinite future. As for which convention is better, that is a controversy quite outside of my scope as a Ledger developer :-) but there is no strong need to change conventions and any good tool should allow you to enter a custom path. Personally, I go with the tezos-client convention because I prefer the command line.
-
命令行默认值不是一成不变的选择,也许值得将其确认为bip44The command line default is not an immutable choice, maybe it might be worth confirming it to bip44
- 1
- 2019-01-29
- Arthur B
Tezos分类帐应用程序的正确BIP-44路径结构是什么?它应该具有五个路径组件(如Galleon所使用)还是四个(如tezos-client和Tezbox所使用)?
BIP-44规范定义了5级路径并在所有示例中全部使用5.最终的"索引"组件是可选的并不明显.
Tezbox和tezos-client似乎默认为
m/44'/1729'/0'/0'
路径,而Galleon默认为m/44'/1729'/0'/0'/0'
.